Office-based Educational Programs

|
Physicians
are facing increasing pressures due to economic factors, changing practice
management procedures, and the complexities of treating patients given
the "new morbidities" and the managed care environment. Finding
time to attend traditional conferences and hospital events can be difficult,
and non-traditional forms of education such as self-study materials, teleconferences,
and Web-based programming are increasing in popularity.
ICAAP has
recently used an office-based approach for its programs that address asthma
diagnosis and treatment, vaccine administration and handling, developmental
screening and referral processes, and tobacco cessation. Presenting programming
at the site where health care is delivered not only enables the sponsor
to reach all health professionals and office staff involved in the delivery
of care but also facilitates personalization of the content and its recommended
techniques to the actual processes employed in the host health care center.
For the physician, the challenges of adapting information received through
continuing education to the practice setting and educating practice colleagues
unable to participate in remote events is greatly reduced through the
office-based approach.
In addition,
reaching a relatively small number of providers through office-based education
can have a significant impact on children. According to the national AAP
Division of Health Policy Research, which produces a biennial report of
the number of pediatricians and other pediatric specialists and children
in each U.S. county, there are approximately 1,700 children per general
practice pediatrician in Illinois (http://www.aap.org/research/workfrc.htm).
Research from the AAP PROS (Pediatric Research in Office Settings) Network
agrees, showing that the average patient population for private pediatric
practitioners nationwide about 1,500. Therefore, presenting a program
in a medium to large (4 or more practitioners) pediatric practice can
ultimately impact literally thousands of children.
Finally,
presenting office-based programming can provide benefits in terms of the
dissemination of quality improvement strategies for practicing physicians
and research into pediatric practice. While lecturers at traditional education
events interact with audience members through discussions and question/answer
sessions, they rarely see the practice environment or meet all participants
involved in the delivery of care in a particular setting. Office-based
education programs not only provide speakers with insight into application
of the curriculum in each practice environment but allow them to identify
new challenges and strategies that can then be incorporated into the presentation
itself. Practice-based research, not unlike that conducted by the AAP
PROS Network and the Pediatric Practice Research Group (PPRG) of Children's
Memorial Hospital, can also be conducted in conjunction with practice-based
educational programs.
Components of a Successful Office-Based Educational Program
Identify
a Topic
Topics for office-based education programs are decided when a need for
continuing education on that topic is evident in current pediatric publications,
at ICAAP/AAP meetings, and/or at members' requests. Once a topic is chosen,
a formal literature review is undertaken and a needs assessment is conducted
by ICAAP or another organization to verify the need for a program on this
topic.
Find a
Sponsor/Grantor
Many state and federal government agencies providing child and family
health and social services request applications for potential grant-funded
programs or seek out organizations that serve particular audiences for
collaboration. Pharmaceutical companies also provide project funding for
continuing medical education, however, ICAAP will only accept these funds
if the Chapter has complete control over the program's curriculum. ICAAP
has contracted to provide office-based education for physicians with the
following sources: Illinois Department of Public Health, Cook County Department
of Public Health, Chicago Department of Public Health, Illinois Council
on Developmental Disabilities, and GlaxoSmithKline.
Establish
a Project Advisory Committee
Once grant funding is secured, the Chapter recruits members for the project's
advisory or planning committee. Advisory committee members usually consist
of physician and nurse specialists in the topic's field and one or two
practicing physicians. Some project committees also have curriculum reviewers
and project liaisons to organizations that concern the program's topic.
After this committee is established, an initial meeting is conducted to
discuss primary planning of the project and its curriculum.
Develop
a Curriculum
Curriculum is developed by the project staff and the advisory committee.
Typically, an initial outline is composed and circulated among committee
members. Then, the presentation itself is drafted by the committee and
revised/edited by project staff. Each program develops project curricula
differently. For example, the Get in the Zone asthma education project
curriculum was drafted by one primary physician and one nurse educator.
Experts prepared and presented individual papers on adolescent smoking
cessation at a one-day panel discussion, after which a professional medical
writer developed a curriculum and materials based on the presentations.
And segments of the developmental screening and immunization education
programs were drafted by multiple advisory committee members and others
and reviewed for consistency and redundancy by staff. Similarly, the materials
collected as resources and handouts for the programs - including relevant
articles, patient education handouts, tip sheets, and even entire manuals
- are identified by multiple participants and collated by staff into a
comprehensive presentation kit.
Curricula
for each project also vary between programs. The teen tobacco use program
consists of a one-hour PowerPoint lecture followed by a question and answer
session. The Reaching our Goals immunization program consists of a comprehensive
curriculum that can be segmented into modules and presented as necessary
based on practices' needs.
Identify
Incentives for Participation
Incentives for a practice to host an office-based program includes flexible
scheduling and the opportunity to integrate the program into the practice's
routines, provision of food or a light meal, and most importantly continuing
medical education (CME) and continuing education (CE) credits. ICAAP staff
applies for and secures continuing medical education hours for participating
physicians and contact education hours for participating nurses. CME/CE
certificates are distributed to program participants after the presentation
for the number of hours attended. Practice leaders also appreciate the
opportunity to provide professional development experiences to members
of their staff while simultaneously increasing their own skills. Finally,
ICAAP has worked with insurers and state and county agencies to promote
programs to providers in their networks, thereby lending weight and authority
to the offer for programming.
Train-the-Trainer
Once grant funding is secured for the program and while curriculum development
occurs, presenters are recruited via the "illinois pediatrician"
newsletter, ICAAP broadcast faxes, and other promotional means. These
presenters are then trained by the advisory committee members and curriculum
authors at a "Train-the-Trainer" workshop. This workshop provides
master trainers with the program materials and information necessary to
train physicians and office staff on the project's topic.
Often, these
trainers are community-based practitioners themselves and commit to teaching
local colleagues - practitioners they already have relationships with
and who share an understanding of unique challenges in particular communities.
Depending on the content, teams of pediatricians, nurses, physician assistants,
and office staff have been identified to handle components of the curriculum
and to train different groups of professionals. This multidisciplinary,
peer-to-peer education approach is key to the success of these programs.
Presentations
The programs are promoted through advisory committee members, ICAAP executive
committee members, and Chapter members at their practices and colleague's
practices. Promotion is also conducted through the newsletter, broadcast
faxes, and mailings.
ICAAP staff
and Advisory Committee members schedule presentations at pediatric practices
and clinics throughout the project target area. For example, the teen
tobacco program was conducted on a statewide basis, so presentations were
scheduled from Champaign and Springfield to Rockford and Barrington. The
immunization program was funded by the Chicago Department of Public Health,
so programs were only scheduled in Chicago. Other programs may target
low-income areas with high Medicaid populations or focus on a particular
county or region in order to better collect outcomes data.
The presentation
is given by the program's master trainers using PowerPoint, case study,
and problem-based/hands-on learning tools. An ICAAP staff member is usually
present at each presentation to facilitate the CME requirements (sign-in
and evaluation procedures), to distribute food (for applicable programs),
and to support the presenter. Programs that require longer than 90 minutes
to present are typically scheduled for two or more office visits.
Evaluation
Procedures
Each program has an evaluation component necessary for CME/CE accreditation
and required by most grantors to assess the effectiveness of the program.
Some programs include a needs assessment to identify the practice's specific
problem areas and requests. All programs utilize a short course evaluation
form that each attendee completes concerning the program presenter, quality
of the program materials and handouts, the question and answer session,
etc. Individual programs have also used different means to evaluate the
overall program's effectiveness including follow-up surveys, focus groups,
and/or chart reviews.
Follow-up/Technical
Assistance
The office presentation is not the only assistance offered to participating
practices. Most programs conduct monthly newsletters, mailings, teleconferences
and/or live sessions to provide participants with updates and changes
to program recommendations. In addition, the Get in the Zone asthma project
and the Reaching Our Goals immunization project provide phone consultations
and other technical assistance to practice leaders by presenters. Consultations
and maintaining contact with the offices support the goal of assessing
each practice's need for repeat or refresher presentations, either to
improve the first visit's impact or to educate new staff members.
|